By XPN MarketingOctober 29, 20265 min read

A lot of wasted Google Ads money in local business accounts doesn’t come from bad ads. It comes from settings. Several of the options that decide where your ads show and what Google optimizes for are set to reach as many people as possible by default, not to reach the people most likely to call you.
The good news is that these are quick to check. Here are nine settings worth looking at today, with links to Google’s own help pages so you can see exactly what each one does.
The short version
Show ads only to people actually in your area, keep Search campaigns on Google Search, review what’s being changed automatically, read your search terms every week, and make sure Google is optimizing for real calls and form leads. Those five habits close the most common leaks.
1. Location targeting includes people who aren’t in your area
When you target a location, Google’s default is “Presence or interest”. According to Google’s page on advanced location options, that reaches people likely to be in your area “as well as people who have shown interest in your targeted locations.” For a Dearborn plumber, that can mean paying for clicks from someone in another state reading about Dearborn.
Fix: in your campaign’s location settings, switch to “Presence” so ads only reach people who are in, or regularly in, the areas you serve. Tourism and destination businesses are the main exception.
2. Search partners are switched on
Google’s page on the Search Network says that when you create a Search campaign, “search partners are included by default.” Search partners are other sites and apps that show Google ads next to their own search results. Sometimes they perform well. Often, for local service businesses, they bring lower-quality clicks.
Fix: compare search partner results with Google Search results in your reports (segment by network). If partners cost more per lead, uncheck “Include Google search partners” in the campaign’s network settings.
3. Your Search campaign is also running on the Display Network
Search campaigns can be set to also show banner-style ads across the web through Display Expansion. That’s a very different audience: people browsing websites, not people searching for your service right now. It can quietly eat a large share of a small budget.
Fix: check the campaign’s network settings and make sure “Include Google Display Network” is off unless you’ve chosen it on purpose. If you want display ads, run them as their own campaign with their own budget.
4. Recommendations are being applied automatically
Google Ads can apply its recommendations for you. Its page on applying recommendations automatically explains that once turned on, “the recommendations will apply regularly.” Some are harmless. Others can add keywords, change match types or change bidding in ways you didn’t plan for.
Fix: open Recommendations, then the auto-apply settings, and turn off anything you’d rather review first. Check the History tab to see what has already been changed.
5. Broad match keywords with nothing to steer them
Broad match lets Google show your ad for a wide range of related searches. Google’s own guidance on broad match with Smart Bidding says the two “pair particularly well”, and also notes that it can take extra budget to reach the added traffic. Broad match on a small budget, without good conversion tracking and negative keywords, is one of the fastest ways to pay for irrelevant searches.
Fix: if your tracking isn’t solid yet, start with phrase and exact match on the services you actually sell. Move to broad match once Google has reliable conversion data to learn from.
6. Nobody is reading the search terms report
Your keywords aren’t the same as the searches you pay for. The search terms report shows the actual searches that triggered your ads. It’s where you’ll find clicks for “jobs”, “salary”, “DIY”, “free” or services you don’t offer.
Fix: look at it every week. Tick the irrelevant terms and add them as negative keywords, ideally to a shared list you use across campaigns.
7. Google is optimizing for the wrong “conversion”
Automated bidding works toward whatever you tell it counts as a conversion. Google’s page on primary and secondary conversion actions explains that primary actions are used for bidding, while secondary ones “are for observation only.” If a page view, a click on your map or a visit to the contact page is set as primary, Google will happily find you more of those, not more customers.
Fix: make calls from ads, calls from your website, and form submissions your primary conversions. Set everything else to secondary.
8. Ads run when nobody can answer the phone
If your ads push people to call and your phone goes to voicemail at night or on Sundays, you’re paying for leads you’ll probably lose to the next business on the list.
Fix: use an ad schedule so call-focused ads run during your open hours. Outside those hours, either pause, lower bids, or send people to a form they can fill in.
9. Every ad goes to your homepage
Someone searching “water heater replacement Dearborn” who lands on a general homepage has to hunt for what they wanted. Many won’t.
Fix: send each group of ads to the page for that exact service, with your phone number at the top and a clear way to book. This is one of the biggest differences between ads that cost money and ads that make money.
15-minute account check
- Location option set to “Presence”?
- Search partners reviewed, and Display Network off in Search campaigns?
- Auto-applied recommendations reviewed?
- Search terms checked this week, with negatives added?
- Only real leads set as primary conversions?
- Ad schedule matches when someone answers the phone?
- Each ad group pointing at the right service page?
When to get help
If you’ve checked all nine and your cost per lead is still too high, the problem is usually deeper: the wrong keywords, weak ads, a slow website, or a market where Local Services Ads might serve you better. And if you’re still deciding whether ads are the right first step at all, read Google Ads vs. SEO for Michigan businesses.
Our Google Ads management starts with exactly this kind of audit, then a clean campaign structure built around the jobs you want more of.
Frequently asked questions
Will turning these settings off reduce my traffic?
Usually a little, and that’s the point. You’ll get fewer clicks from people outside your area or with no intent to buy, so more of your budget goes to people who might call.
How often should I check my Google Ads account?
Look at search terms and leads weekly. Review settings, auto-applied changes and conversion setup once a month, and whenever results change suddenly.
Are Google’s recommendations bad?
No, some are useful. The issue is letting them apply without anyone checking whether they fit your business and budget.
What’s a good cost per lead?
It depends on your industry, area and how much a customer is worth to you. The useful question is whether your leads turn into enough paying jobs to make the ads profitable.
Want a second pair of eyes on your account?
Call us and we’ll talk through what your ads are costing and where the waste usually hides, or run our free competitor analysis to see how you stack up on Google locally.
Keep reading
Written by the team at XPN Marketing, a marketing agency in Dearborn, MI.